Homemade vs. Restaurant Pizza: Ingredients, Techniques and Flavours Compared

There’s something undeniably enticing about a freshly baked pizza, whether it’s coming out of your home oven or being served at a cosy restaurant like 11 Inch Pizza in Melbourne.

But when it comes to the ultimate pizza experience, how does homemade pizza stack up against restaurant pizza?

Let’s delve into the world of pizza-making to compare ingredients, techniques, and flavours.

Pizza dough recipes

The Ingredients: Quality and Variety

When it comes to ingredients, restaurant pizzas like those we craft at 11 Inch Pizza have a distinct edge. We source high-quality, often locally-sourced ingredients, ensuring each component of the pizza – from the dough to the toppings – is of the finest quality. While homemade pizzas can be delicious, accessing the variety and quality of ingredients that a restaurant can procure might be challenging for the average home cook.

Dough: The Foundation

The dough is the foundation of any pizza. At 11 Inch Pizza, our dough is meticulously handcrafted, allowed to proof for just the right amount of time to develop complex flavours and an ideal texture. Achieving this level of perfection in homemade pizza dough can be a tall order for home cooks, given the nuances of kneading, resting, and temperature control.

If you still want to give it a crack at home, take a look at our post How to Make Pizza Dough at Home: The Ultimate Chef’s Guide, or Surprising Pizza Dough Recipes.

Toppings: A Symphony of Flavours

Restaurants have the advantage of offering a wide array of toppings, often including gourmet and specialty options. At 11 Inch Pizza, our topping combinations are crafted to create a symphony of flavours that are hard to replicate in home kitchens. While homemade pizzas offer the joy of customisation, they might lack the innovative and diverse topping combinations found in a restaurant setting.

Cooking Techniques: The Heat Factor

Cooking techniques play a vital role in the pizza’s final taste and texture. Restaurant pizzas are typically cooked in specialized ovens that reach higher temperatures than home ovens, resulting in a perfectly charred crust and evenly melted toppings. While homemade pizza has its charm, replicating the crisp crust and perfectly cooked toppings of a restaurant pizza can be a challenge at home.

Consistency and Expertise

Consistency is another area where restaurant pizza shines. At 11 Inch Pizza, our chefs are skilled in the art of pizza making, ensuring that each pizza is cooked to perfection. This level of consistency is often hard to achieve with homemade pizzas, where results can vary with each attempt.

The Dining Experience

Beyond just the pizza itself, dining at a restaurant offers an experience. The ambiance, the service, and the joy of having a freshly made pizza served right to your table add to the allure of restaurant pizza. It’s an experience that encompasses more than just the taste of the pizza, something that’s hard to replicate in a home setting.

While there’s a certain charm to making homemade pizza at home, restaurant pizza, especially from an establishment like 11 Inch Pizza in Melbourne, offers a superior experience. The quality of ingredients, expert cooking techniques, and the delightful dining atmosphere make restaurant pizza an unbeatable choice. Next time you’re craving a slice, remember that nothing quite compares to the flavours, textures, and experience of a restaurant-quality pizza.

If you’re still keen to make homemade pizza, we suggest starting here:

Alternatively, you can order online now—enjoy own delicious pizza from the comfort of your own home.

11 Inch Pizza Delivery Locations


Minimum order for delivery is $35 in CBD (inc Free Delivery) and $40 outside of CBD (+$5 Delivery Fee). Click here to see our delivery zone mapFor small orders or customers outside of this delivery zone, please use the UberEats app.